I know you have your answer but might I just say that I have had my HP laptop for just over two years now and it is still functioning fine.
I take really bad care of it, leave it on for days at a time, keep it constantly on charge, never change the battery (I only have one and it lasts for about twenty minutes), hardly ever update it, don't clean out the fans regularly (pretty much everything you're supposed to do, I don't do) and it is still fine.
In short, my HP is a beast. I wouldn't tell people NOT to buy one, because mine has been a pretty nice machine. I game on it too and haven't had any problems.
The same with my six year old acer laptop. That thing is amazing. I damaged the cooling system, the graphics (it had an inbuilt graphics...thingy), pretty much everything there is to damage and it is still working fine. When I took it to the computer shop the guy was so amazed that it was still working without a glitch ^^
The only thing wrong with my HP is the occasional weird noises from the fans (my fault) and the keys keep falling off. My letter 'k' key has been loose for a year and my spacebar is getting a little dodgy
Toshiba seems the way to go though. My friend has a Toshiba and as far as I know he has had no problems with it whatsoever ^^
Edit: What are you using your laptop for, might I ask? Gaming, surfing the web? Because going to an actual store might help you get an idea what laptop will suit your needs. Just because it isn't a Toshiba doesn't mean it isn't good.