I think that eventually you will decide to come up with more than fantasy blue and fantasy black in the style chooser and I suggest that one of the styles be mostly pink. The shade of pink I prefer according to wikipedia is rose, but I'm not picky as long as it isn't any closer to the fuchsia family and also no darker. An option would be mixing it with a shade of gray, brown, or grayish-brown to tone it down and make it look more modern if you'd like, but it's entirely up to you, clearly.
Another suggestion is that you would have an html contest for a few of the styles whenever Aarinfantasy is up for it. This will allow you to choose weed out the insane while still getting a few fresh ideas that you can still tweak.
I'm adamant about the pink thing but the forum style contest would be nifty too.