aarinfantasy's YAOI Collection

View Poll Results: Vote for your fav review

Voters
29. This poll is closed
  • Review #1

    8 27.59%
  • Review #2

    3 10.34%
  • Review #3

    18 62.07%
Results 1 to 5 of 5
  1. #1
    Flurry of Dancing Flames


    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    following Victuri and Otayuri to all their performances to watch their cute moments together ♥
    Posts
    6,504
    Points
    507,601,530
    Savings
    17,578,866


    Midoriya Izuku (L3)Bakugou (L3)Todoroki Shouto (L3)
    Otabek Altin (L8)Yuri Plisetsky (L9)Otabek Altin (L9)
    Axel (L10)(S096) Rei Izumi(S099) Dick Burnford

    VOTE: Manga Review of The Month (MROTM) - Dec. 2016

    Please vote for your fav review.

    Review #1


    Review #2


    Review #3

  2. #2
    Total Yaoi Freak

    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    St. STFU
    Posts
    1,682
    Points
    981,008,362
    Savings
    999,755,900


    POTM - 1 StarMakima (L10)SOTM - 2 Stars
    Denji (L9)Power (L7)Aki Hayakawa (L8)
    Makima (L9)Makima (L8)Gojo Satoru (L9)

    I voted for #3 because it comes across as most to the point to me and makes it really easy to grasp information without trying very hard to understand. All reviews are pretty good though!

  3. #3
    Smile, breath and go slow


    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Home sweet home...
    Posts
    1,268
    Points
    81,673,247
    Savings
    33,845,000


    Ayace (L9)Heart 6 (Devil)Canale (L9)
    Emba (L10)MeatBunYuuen (L9)
    (S067) Azumaya Junta(S054) Prompto Argentum(S076) SilverAsh

    #1 gives a good idea of what the story will bring, it summarizes the different points (character development, plot, not so much about the art)

    #3 is similar, though more organised. in this sense, probably easier to see the different points one would look at based on their preferences. Would one want to know about the art, the characters, the plot... it would be easier to just focus on that reading.

    #2 feels more like an introduction, a presentation of the Manhwa, not much a review, though it gives also input on whether one would want to read it or not...

    I voted for #1, this one review told me what I am looking for in a story/manga: whether the characters/plot were relatable or not, and about their development. I like to know if I will be looking at just some pretty art or if I will be able to read about the evolution of a character (or multiple)... I like the dive in the human nature, and to know if an author/artist is able to depict it...

  4. #4
    Yaoi Expert

    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    umm...here?
    Posts
    1,171
    Points
    8,797,694
    Savings
    1,246,985


    Natori (L10)Strawberry Cake 1Natsume (L10)
    Fire PhoenixHeart 4 (Rainbow)MeatBun
    Kei Nagai (L7)Edward (L10)Jin Ling (L2)

    #3 was it for me because I really love the section-style. All of the reviews were well done, and #1 was very close for me because it made the "not sectioned" style work out nicely, and gave a rating. [It's not that #2 was bad, just that it had very serious competition.]

  5. #5
    BL 'til I die!


    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    4,652
    Points
    340,019,178
    Savings
    126,499,193


    Jaehee (L5)For Me (Xmas)Spacer 1
    Spacer 1Spacer 1Dai Lee (L5)
    Spacer 1Spacer 1Heart 4 (Rainbow)

    This round is pretty difficult. While reading I thought that each reviewer has a difficult task in choosing what kind of format would suit best the review.

    I think my point is that some titles are more challenging than others and in that sense, a good review could not shine as well as others just by a matter of form. For example, 3rd review was nice, the reviewer got perfectly well Aniya-sensei's touch but the review doesn't show the manga's uniqueness and I think it's due to the segmented format.

    On the other hand, review #1 & #2 were flexible and fresh. They convey the reviewer's mind and have personality per se. I liked how number 1 even gave us the image of starting the day with a light smutty BL manga.

    So I voted for what I consider a good review regardless of my own manga preferences.
    Good job everyone!

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •